| 1952 | James Slater (Provisional CO) | |||
| 1952 | THRU | 1953 | Elliot Morris (1st CO) | |
| 1953 | THRU | 1954 | Wayne Zeh | |
| 1954 | THRU | 1955 | Gorden Stockhammer | |
| 1954 | THRU | 1955 | Eugene Aleshin | |
| 1954 | THRU | 1955 | Robert Weston | |
| 1955 | THRU | 1956 | James Finger | |
| 1957 | THRU | 1958 | Jan L'Homidieu | |
| 1957 | THRU | 1958 | Anthony Broullon | |
| 1957 | THRU | 1958 | Harvey Corbett | |
| 1958 | THRU | 1959 | Robert King | |
| 1959 | THRU | 1960 | Richard S. Laskin | |
| 1960 | THRU | 1961 | Joseph R. Turberg, Jr. | |
| 1961 | THRU | 1961 | John Lepore | |
| 1961 | THRU | 1962 | John Aloisio | |
| 1962 | THRU | 1963 | Michael Flynn | |
| 1963 | THRU | 1964 | John Gonzalez | |
| 1964 | THRU | 1965 | A.J. Habersberger | |
| 1965 | THRU | 1966 | Bruce Allen Harris | |
| 1966 | THRU | 1967 | Richard Cacciato | |
| 1967 | THRU | 1968 | Barry Kaplan | |
| 1968 | THRU | 1969 | Henry Scarangella | |
| 1969 | THRU | 1970 | John Reisenberger | |
| 1970 | THRU | 1971 | Vincent Scatamaccia | |
| 1971 | THRU | 1972 | Lester Albers | |
| 1972 | THRU | 1973 | Robert Scherer | |
| 1973 | THRU | 1974 | Joseph Tombrello | |
| 1974 | THRU | 1975 | Nelson Migdal | |
| 1975 | THRU | 1976 | Brian O'Connell | |
| 1976 | THRU | 1977 | Leo Martinez | |
| 1977 | THRU | 1978 | Nick Florio | |
| 1978 | THRU | 1979 | Pat Higgins | |
| 1979 | THRU | 1980 | Mike Hallisey | |
| 1980 | THRU | 1981 | Bob Cutajar | |
| 1981 | THRU | 1982 | Bill Roston | |
| 1982 | THRU | 1982 | Ronald Midgette | |
| 1982 | THRU | 1982 | Frank Tartaglia | |
| 1983 | THRU | 1983 | William J. Wagner, Jr. | |
| 1983 | THRU | 1984 | Joseph Chirico | |
| 1984 | THRU | 1985 | Enrico Squeri | |
| 1985 | THRU | 1986 | Derek Elliott | |
| 1986 | THRU | 1987 | Arthur Hoffman | |
| 1987 | THRU | 1988 | Mike Flagler | |
| 1988 | THRU | 1989 | Richard Donoghue | |
| 1989 | THRU | 1990 | Anthony Senft, Jr. | |
| 1990 | THRU | 1991 | Matthew Zvolensky | |
| 1991 | THRU | 1992 | James Donovan | |
| 1992 | THRU | 1993 | David Barrett | |
| 1993 | THRU | 1994 | Adam Augustowski | |
| 1994 | THRU | 1995 | Carlos Panchana | |
| 1995 | THRU | 1996 | Edgar Kanapathy | |
| 1996 | THRU | 1997 | Brain Carbone | |
| 1997 | THRU | 1998 | Matthew Valas | |
| 1998 | THRU | 1999 | Rea Greaves | |
| 1999 | THRU | 2000 | Philip Grosso | |
| 2000 | THRU | 2001 | None | |
| 2001 | THRU | 2002 | Tim Hendrickson | |
| 2002 | THRU | 2003 | James Gramstead | |
| 2003 | THRU | 2003 | Robert Morris | |
| 2003 | THRU | 2004 | Jennifer Brown | |
| 2004 | THRU | 2005 | Barry Parker | |
| 2005 | THRU | 2006 | Jason Newby | |
| 2006 | THRU | 2007 | Arlen DelCastillo | |
| 2007 | THRU | 2007 | William Lembo | |
| 2007 | THRU | 2008 | William Cosgrove | |
| 2008 | THRU | 2009 | Mateo Belford | |
| 2009 | THRU | 2010 | Alex McHale | |
| 2010 | THRU | 2011 | Alexandria Wiedenbaum | |
| 2011 | THRU | 2012 | Christopher Morrison |